Risk management

Measuring What Matters: A Practical Guide to Active Risk Under the Total Portfolio Approach

As plan sponsors move from Strategic Asset Allocation (SAA) to Total Portfolio Approach (TPA), wider flexibility demands a new approach to measuring active risk.

Key Takeaways 

  • TPA replaces rigid asset-class targets with a broader reference portfolio and a wider active risk budget
  • Forward-looking ex-ante risk analytics become essential for managing total portfolios effectively under the TPA framework
  • BNY Risk View uses a full-revaluation security-level approach to build confidence in portfolio risk outputs
  • Best practices start with the risk question and measure ex-ante risk to course correct in real time

 

A Wider Budget Demands a Sharper Lens

As more U.S. plan sponsors move from Strategic Asset Allocation (SAA) to a Total Portfolio Approach (TPA), they gain greater flexibility to allocate capital to the opportunities they view as most attractive on a risk-adjusted basis. This flexibility helps them respond more effectively to changing market conditions in pursuit of greater alpha across the plan. However, it also carries a wider active risk budgets, making forward-looking risk measurement more essential to managing the portfolio.

But measuring active risk under TPA is not simply a matter of widening the budget. It requires a different lens — one that decomposes risk across the total portfolio, stress-tests decisions before they’re made and treats analytics as an input into allocation, not just a report on it.

The Shift from SAA to TPA

The key difference is flexibility, and that shift  changes how we measure and manage risk.

Under SAA, teams operate within board-approved asset class targets and ranges, with limited scope for tactical positioning within those parameters. Active risk, typically measured as tracking error, the expected volatility of returns relative to a benchmark, stays tightly bounded. The board and investment teams manage it at two levels: a total-plan budget of 2–3%, and narrower risk budgets at the asset-class budget level.

Under TPA, the emphasis shifts from “Are we close to our strategic weights?” to “Are we taking the right risks across the total portfolio to generate additional alpha in pursuit of our objectives?” Instead of managing against a traditional policy benchmark, the plan may adopt a broader reference portfolio; for example, 75% MSCI ACWI IMI Net / 25% Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate. The team still operates within an active risk budget, but it may be wider, for example 4–5% versus 2–3% under SAA, giving investment teams greater flexibility while preserving disciplined oversight of total portfolio risk.

Same Portfolio, Different Lens

The same portfolio shows a 1-year ex-ante (forward-looking) tracking error of 2.3% against an SAA policy benchmark — but 4.0% against a broader TPA reference benchmark. The portfolio itself has not changed. What has changed is the lens through risk is measured.

Sample Total Plan: SAA (Data as of December 31, 2025)

Asset ClassMarket ValueBenchmark WeightContribution to 1-Year Ex-Ante Tracking Error
Total Plan 1-Year Ex-Ante
Tracking Error
  2.3%
Absolute Return19.9%20.0%10.2%
Fixed Income10.3%10.0%6.8%
Private Equity17.4%20.0%54.7%
Public Equity34.5%35.0%12.1%
Real Assets17.8%15.0%16.1%

Sample Total Plan: TPA (Data as of December 31, 2025)

Total PortfolioMarket Value1-Year Ex-Ante Tracking
Error
Reference Benchmark
Total100.0%4.0%TPA 75/25 Reference
Benchmark

The example also illustrates why looking beyond allocation weights matters: a relatively smaller portfolio allocation can account for a disproportionate share of active risk.

Why Risk Analytics Is Critical under TPA

Greater flexibility makes robust risk measurement more important, not less. A team operating with  a wider active risk budget and greater discretion needs confidence in its ex-ante view of risk today — rather than waiting years for realized ex-post (backward-looking) tracking error to show, after the fact, how those risks played out.

4 Questions Every Team Should Answer Continuously

#1

How much active risk are we assuming?

#2

Where is that risk coming from?

#3

Which positions, managers, and asset classes are driving it?

#4

What happens to portfolio risk if we reallocate capital, add a new investment or appoint a prospective manager?

Under TPA, risk analytics move beyond measurement and become an input into portfolio construction. Teams can decompose ex-ante active risk at the manager, asset-class and total-plan levels — and run what-if analysis to test allocation decisions before implementing them. In practical terms, this reframes the question from simply measuring risk to asking: “If we make this investment decision, what happens to our total portfolio risk?” These capabilities are valuable under either framework but become increasingly important as investment teams gain greater flexibility to allocate across the total portfolio.

Confidence in the Risk Engine Matters

Investment decisions are only as good as the risk analytics that support them. At BNY, our risk framework — BNY Risk View, developed in partnership with Innocap — employs a complex risk methodology (a full revaluation) security-level approach to calculate risk. BNY Risk View uses Axioma’s Multi-Asset Class risk model as the core model is a holdings-based, scenario-driven security level risk model. BNY Risk View supports Monte Carlo, Historical, VaR and Relative VaR methodologies, along with deep-sensitivity and stress-testing capabilities.

The reason this matters is practical, not theoretical: a full-revaluation, security-level approach gives investment teams the granularity and transparency to understand risk down to the position level. That, in turn, helps build confidence in the risk outputs that inform portfolio construction, active risk budgeting and investment decisions.

Best Practices: A Checklist

Best Practices for Asset Owners under TPA

  • Start with the risk question, not the tool. Define the decisions the team needs to make — decomposing risk, testing allocations, stress-testing — and let those requirements drive the framework choice.
  • Measure ex-ante risk to make investment decisions — don’t wait for ex-post risk to be realized. Forward-looking tracking error lets teams course-correct in real time; waiting years for realized results turns risk management into an autopsy.
  • Decompose risk to its sources. The total number is necessary but not sufficient — teams need to see which positions, managers, and asset classes are driving it.
  • Treat risk analytics as an allocation input, not just a report. The most valuable use is pre-decision: running what-if analysis before reallocating, not measuring the outcome after.
  • Demand sufficient transparency and granularity for more robust Monte Carlo simulations. Security-level analysis can help teams understand what is driving risk and build confidence in the numbers informing allocation decisions.
  • Anchor accountability in human judgment. Analytics inform decisions; they don’t make them. The team — not the engine — owns the allocation.

Looking Ahead

The transition from SAA to TPA is not a binary one; it runs along a spectrum. What unites every plan along that spectrum is a common imperative: as investment flexibility increases, the analytics used to measure and manage risk must keep pace.

The plan most likely to succeed will pair broader discretion with equally robust risk analytics — understanding how much forward-looking active risk they are taking, where that risk comes from, and how individual decisions may change it. Whether operating under SAA or TPA, or transitioning between the two, the practical question is the same: “Do we have the robust risk measurement capabilities and tools in place to use our flexibility deliberately to create alpha?”.

That is the question every plan sponsor should be asking, and the answer requires analytics that can decompose risk to the position level, stress-test decisions before they're made, and keep pace with the flexibility TPA demands.

Continue Exploring Best Practices for Asset Owners

From risk to data management, our Best Practices series explores the practical capabilities asset owners need to navigate change and make confident decisions. Next, explore A Different Lens on Data: Driving Innovation and Insight Through Data Best Practices

BNY is the corporate brand of The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation and may be used to reference the corporation as a whole or its various subsidiaries generally. This material and any products and services mentioned may be issued or provided in various countries by duly authorized and regulated subsidiaries, affiliates, and joint ventures of BNY. This material does not constitute a recommendation by BNY of any kind. The information herein is not intended to provide tax, legal, investment, accounting, financial or other professional advice on any matter, and should not be used or relied upon as such. The views expressed within this material are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of BNY. BNY has not independently verified the information contained in this material and makes no representation as to the accuracy, completeness, timeliness, merchantability or fitness for a specific purpose of the information provided in this material. BNY assumes no direct or consequential liability for any errors in or reliance upon this material.

This material may not be reproduced or disseminated in any form without the express prior written permission of BNY. BNY will not be responsible for updating any information contained within this material and opinions and information contained herein are subject to change without notice. Trademarks, service marks, logos and other intellectual property marks belong to their respective owners.

© 2026 BNY. All rights reserved. Member FDIC.

Related Platforms

Fund & Investor Solutions
Fund and investor servicing for growth, insight and efficiency.
Asset Owners
Solutions to help build resilient portfolios, enhance liquidity flexibility and scale operations through transparent oversight and connected infrastructure.

READY TO GROW YOUR BUSINESS?