Bubble or is this market different?
The S&P 500 is up 14% year to date after gaining more than 20% annually over the past couple of years. Valuations are certainly elevated, but we believe the market is in a new world where higher multiples are normal rather than stretched.
3 min Reading time
Published on 21 October 2025
The S&P 500 is up 14% year to date after gaining more than 20% annually over the past couple of years. Some investors are speculating that we are amidst another tech bubble because technology companies have been leading the market higher. However, we believe the market is in a new world where higher multiples are normal rather than a sign of stretched valuations.
For some context, the S&P 500’s 12-month future price-to-earnings (PE) ratio is currently 22.4x, notably greater than the 16.8x average since 1996. While the index appears expensive relative to history, we believe this higher-multiple environment is justified. A key reason is the improved profitability of the market; net margins are 1.6x higher at 14% compared to the dot.com era. Similarly, free cash flow margins are 1.9x higher at 11%. In addition, the weight of the technology sector, which has the highest PE, has increased 1.6x since the dot.com era to 35% of the index. This naturally increases the PE of the index.
The changing market structure with the increased size of tech and the broader index’s higher profitability have led to higher PEs compared to long-term averages. In our view, the disconnect between current valuations and historical averages reflects a different type of market – not an overvalued one.
So, while we don’t believe the market is in a bubble, we believe that investors’ skepticism is healthy for keeping bull markets intact. Current valuations could consolidate from elevated levels, but we remain constructive on the forward outlook given improving earnings.
825124 Exp : 21 October 2026
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
Small caps have outperformed this year despite the threat of higher interest rates, suggesting the rally is being driven by more than just diversification away from large cap tech stocks. Improving earnings expectations and a resilient U.S. economy support our view that small caps have further upside from here.
Signs from sales
Signs from Sales
Year-to-date stock market returns have been driven by robust earnings growth. But when assessing the equity outlook, it’s important to ask what’s supporting the strong earnings trend.
The S&P 500’s history shows that despite recessions, wars, inflation, and corrections, the market’s long-term trajectory has remained upward. As the U.S. marks 250 years of resilience, the lesson for investors is clear: wealth is built through patience, discipline and staying invested.
U.S. policy uncertainty has remained elevated and consumer sentiment has weakened. Even so, the economy has stayed resilient, and because growth has held up better than sentiment and headlines suggest, we continue to forecast 2% U.S. growth in 2026, in line with trend.
